0 $
2,500 $
5,000 $
51 $
JUNE 2020

Finian Cunningham: “US Duplicity over Golan Demolishes Posturing on Crimea”


Written by Finian Cunningham; Originally appeared on strategic-culture.org

In a controversial snub to international law, the United States signaled last week that it is moving to officially recognize the Golan Heights as part of Israeli territory. If the US does so, then it forfeits any moral authority to sanction Russia over allegations of “annexing Crimea”.

In its annual US State Department report, the section dealing with the Golan Heights reportedly refers to the contested area as “Israeli-controlled”, not “Israeli-occupied”. The change in wording deviates from United Nations resolutions and international norm which use the term “Israeli-occupied” to designate the land Israel annexed from Syria following the 1967 Six Day War.

Finian Cunningham: "US Duplicity over Golan Demolishes Posturing on Crimea"

Israel has occupied the western part of the Golan since 1967 as a spoil from that war. In 1981, Tel Aviv formally annexed the Syrian territory. However, the UN Security Council in 1981, including the US, unanimously condemned the annexation as illegal. The resolution mandates Israel to return the land to Syria which has historical claim to the entire Golan. The area of 1,800 square kilometers is a strategic elevation overlooking the northern Jordan Valley.

If Washington confirms its recent indications of recognizing the Golan as officially part of Israel, the development would mark an egregious flouting of international law.

But what’s more, such a move totally prohibits Washington from posturing with presumed principle over the issue of Crimea, the Black Sea peninsula which since 2014 voluntarily became part of Russia.

Just last month, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo repeated accusations against Russia of “annexing” Crimea. Pompeo insisted that US sanctions against Moscow would be maintained until Russia “returns Crimea to Ukraine”.

“The world has not forgotten the cynical lies Russia employed to justify its aggression and mask its attempted annexation of Ukrainian territory,” he said. “The United States will maintain respective sanctions against Russia until the Russian government returns control of Crimea to Ukraine.”

Last year, Pompeo’s State Department issued a ‘Crimea Declaration’ in which it was stated that, “Russia undermines a bedrock of international principle shared by democratic states: that no country can change the borders of another by force.”

Claims by Washington and the European Union of “illegal annexation” of Crimea by Russia are the central basis for five years of economic sanctions imposed on Moscow. Those sanctions have contributed to ever-worsening tensions with Russia and the build-up of NATO forces along Russia’s borders.

Those claims are, however, highly contestable. The people of Crimea voted in a legally constituted referendum in March 2014 to secede from Ukraine and to join the Russian Federation. That referendum followed an illegal coup in Kiev in February 2014 backed by the US and Europe against a legally elected president, Viktor Yanukovych. Historically, Crimea has centuries of shared cultural heritage with Russia. Its erstwhile position within the state of Ukraine was arguably an anomaly of the Cold War and subsequent break-up of the Soviet Union.

In any case, there is scant comparison between the Golan Heights and Crimea, save, that is, for the latest hypocrisy in Washington. While Crimea and its people are arguably historically part of Russia, the Golan Heights are indisputably a sovereign part of Syria which was forcibly annexed by Israeli military occupation.

The illegality of Israel’s occupation of Golan is a matter of record under international law as stipulated in UNSC Resolution 497.

There is no such international mandate concerning Crimea. Claims of Russia’s “annexation” are simply a matter of dubious political assertion made by Washington and its European allies.

The latest move by Washington towards recognizing Golan as part of Israel – in defiance of international law – comes on the back of several other recent developments.

US Republican Senator Lindsey Graham made a tour of Israeli-occupied Golan last week in the company of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, pointedly transported by an IDF military helicopter. Graham said following his tour that he would recommend the Trump administration to officially recognize the area as under Israeli sovereignty.

Currently, there is legislation going through both the US Senate and House of Representatives which is aimed at declaring the entire Golan as Israeli territory.

The stark shift in pro-Israeli bias in Washington under the Trump administration is consistent with the White House declaring at the end of 2017 that Jerusalem is the capital of Israel. Again, that move by President Trump overturned international consensus and UN resolutions which have stipulated Jerusalem to be a shared capital between Israel and a future Palestinian state, to be worked out by (defunct) peace negotiations.

Why Washington has taken up the Golan issue as a prize for Israel at this time is not precisely clear. It could be seen as the Trump administration giving a political boost to Netanyahu for next month’s elections.

There has been previous speculation that Trump is doing the bidding for a US-based oil company, Genie Oil, which is linked to his administration through his son-in-law Jared Kushner’s family investments. The New Jersey company has a subsidiary in Israel, is tied to the Netanyahu government, and has long been aiming to drill the Golan for its abundant oil resources.

The Golan move could also be retribution meted out to Syrian President Bashar al-Assad over his country’s historic defeat of the US-backed covert war for regime change. The nearly eight-year war was also covertly backed by Israel which sponsored jihadist militia operating out of the Golan against the Syrian army. Having vanquished the US regime-change plot, thanks to crucial military support from Russia, Iran and Hezbollah, the payback could be Washington stepping up Israeli claims to annex the Golan.

But whatever the background explanation is, the initiative by Washington to legalize the annexation of Golan by Israel is a brazen violation of international law. In doing so, the US is officially sponsoring war crimes and theft of Syria’s sovereign territory. Or as the Crimea Declaration would put it: “changing the borders of another country by force” – supposedly a “bedrock principle” that Washington continually sermonizes about to Russia.

Crimea and Golan are different issues of territorial dispute, as noted already. Nevertheless, the duplicity of Washington over Golan makes its posturing on Crimea null and void. If the Europeans meekly go along with the US move on Golan, then they too should shut their mouths and their moralizing sanctions over Crimea.



Do you like this content? Consider helping us!

  • Zionism = EVIL

    More importantly the whole so-called “west” hypocrisy over the illegal Zionist occupation of Palestine, not to mention Indians occupying Kashmir and so on. In the law of jungle created by baboon Americanus, might is right.

    • Jens Holm

      a.s.o. a.s.o. a.s.o. gadagung gadagung.

      Hard to see any zionist and americans in Kashmir as well. Its local and added some Chinese as well.

  • Real Anti-Racist Action

    The USSA annexed Hawaii. Since then the US has had no moral authority to say to anyone anything.
    The U.S. invades Japan in the 1850’s (something most people are to dumbed down by Hollywood to know about)
    The opening skirmishes in the United States of America’s war against Asia took place in Japan. While they have been portrayed as minor incidents in most histories, they had major effects. The success of these military acts encouraged leaders of the USA to continue on a military course that would lead to over a century of nearly continuous warfare. Millions of Asians, both civilians and soldiers, would die as a direct result of military action. The modernization of Japan that resulted from its need to defend itself from the United States would result in a Japanese war policy that hurt other Asian nations more than it ultimately hurt the USA.

    The USA and its allies were entirely the evil bad colonizers both before during and after the 2nd world war.
    Humans have the human right to self defense of their indigenous ancestral tribal home lands.
    Up the brave White Russians who fought tooth and nail against bigots such as Georgian-supremacist-bigot-Stalin the butcher of the Russian people.

  • Saddam Hussein

    Syria has to understand that the only way to regain the Golan Heights is by forcing the Zionist regime out. They cant depend on the UN, EU or the US in this.

    • Jens Holm

      Much more like You and Co should learn, that facts are facts. I have heard both sides of that since 1967 as well as feeding Westbankers and Gazaists.

      You both are dirty hostage takers of the worst kind Yourself. Go home and fry something.

  • Daniel Martin

    If the U.S actually proceeds with this illegal act it will just further erode the U.S already heavily tarnished international law reputation, It is acts like this and those like Venezuela, Syria Ukraine, Afghanistan, Yugoslavia/Serbia and many many more, that has made the U.S and it’s so called “allies” look like clowns on the international stage. The above mentioned reasons are the main reasons why the world is looking for alternatives like Russia,China,Iran and now even Turkey (a NATO ally) to the U.S erratic and unreliable behavior.

  • goingbrokes

    The elites do not care about international law, they never have and never will. So I see this as an attempt to goad Syria into attacking israel (to reclaim Golan). But I hope the Syrians won’t do any such thing. Israel is running out of options and they are trying to ignite another war without apparently starting it. So that they can start using their nukes on their neighbours, presumably.

    Time is not on the side of the state of israel, but time is on the Syrian side. Those who will play the long game now will win in the end. The status quo actually now favours Syria, Lebanon and Iran. Only israel thrives on chaos.

    I think legally the Syrians should reinforce their declaring of Golan heights to be Syrian territory, and send the government of israel land rental bills for the use of Golan heights backdated to 1967 at about $1billion/year. They should deliver these bills to israel publicly at the UN meetings once year. The bills should stipulate that the rental does not cover any usage or exploitation of underground resources in the Golan Heights area. In addition they should send them claims of compensation for each syrian citizen who has suffered from israel’s presence in the Golan Heights. Play the game.

  • Xoli Xoli

    USA itself exists out of forcefully annex states. Let USA breakup.illegal oppress USA state Washington administration steal territory of Syria. Washington administration forcefully decides over land grabbing. Their appointed Poroshenko who is destroying Ukraine.Washington appointed Hariri in Lebanon.Washington appointed small boy Guiado in Venezuela. Washington declared Jerusalem Israeli Capital.Washington wringle face decision makers annexed Guam,occupy Japan,Germany, Iraq,Syria.Washington appointed and fire Sakasvilli.